Monday, October 31, 2011

Connection: Shakespeare and Music

              Poetry and music, music and poetry. The connection is frequently made, but for me, digging deeper into Shakespeare has made this connection more meaningful. The first time I ever read Shakespeare was last year, with Romeo and Juliet. I noticed the language right away—beautiful, rhythmic, sometimes cryptic as it is—but it was only in English class that I began to see how finely crafted Shakespeare’s language really is, and I think that this discovery can also be made in music.

One thing Shakespeare masters is rhythm, and rhythm is essential to music. The flow and sound of a piece allow the listener to follow along and give it a feeling of its own. The same is true for Shakespeare’s works. Rhythm and emphasis add feeling to a grouping of individual words, just like in music they give feeling to a grouping of individual notes.

At first I only understood this rhythm in the bigger picture of Shakespeare’s writing’s pleasing sound, but upon being prompted to take a deeper look I found that he indeed uses intentional elements of repetition, structure, and length. This structure is essential to the enjoyment of the piece. Shakespeare could use the most beautiful words there ever were, but without his creative phrasing and patterning his work wouldn’t be as effective. In music, notes need organization through rhythm as well as creative placement to be interpreted in a meaningful way. It seems that great artists use rhythm so well that the notes or words seem to fall together naturally ; when seeing the work from above, you don’t notice how intricately planned the rhythms are. Further analysis reveals the wonderful elaborate details in structure that create that more abstract “flow” and feeling.

                Performance is also a key part of both Shakespeare and music. Both are made for performance but can be read by one person and interpreted inwardly using imagination. I believe that performance, as the purpose of these works, brings fuller meaning to them. Shakespeare’s works can be read silently, but as plays they are meant for a range of actors and directors who all combine their interpretations of his intent into something much more complicated and artful than one person could think of alone. Music is the same way. Each musician brings their own feeling and technique into a piece, no matter how slightly, and these personal elements add unique meaning to the result. This puts responsibility on the performer—they strive to get as close as they can to the exact work, but also let their interpretation play a part.

There are so many ways that Shakespeare’s writing and music mirror each other. Recently, these connections have helped me to understand both things better, and now I see why their beauty is so well renown. The craft that Shakespeare uses is also used by great composers; both carefully and tactically shape each tiny part to make a tremendous final product. Music and Shakespeare can both be very pleasing on the surface, but an even greater enjoyment can be found by diving in.

Thursday, October 20, 2011

360 Degrees: “Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening” by Robert Frost

On the first day of our poetry unit, a classmate shared this poem with me. I read, and saw in it beauty and peace. When I told my classmate that I liked it, they said they did too, but they were surprised that with this type of writing Frost wasn’t terribly depressed or suicidal. I was thoroughly confused. How did we, in the same poem, find both dark loneliness and quiet content?

Our reactions were so different because we each saw the poem at a different angle. One such angle is to find the emotions in the poem of solitude and weariness. The idea that the narrator stops without any people nearby for no apparent reason other than the dark beauty of the woods is a solemn one. He is all by himself and has a long way to go. Perhaps he is losing motivation to carry on. The last lines read “and miles to go before I sleep,” but what kind of sleep is this? It could be a more somber sleep than the one we get every night. It’s the picture of loneliness: alone save his horse in a winter wood, bare and cold and filling with snow, with a long journey ahead of him. It seems that the narrator wishes he had nowhere to go and no promises to keep, for then he could just have his sleep or rest in the woods as he watches them fill with snow.

At the same time, the poem could be seen in a more positive light. Frost certainly paints a beautiful picture of the woods on this evening. His descriptions are vivid but tranquil: the filling of the woods, sweeping of wind and downy flakes, and lovely, dark, deep woods. They all use flowing, soft sounds to convey the still and wonderful scene. The journey of the narrator could also be viewed as something pleasant; it could be a challenge but worth the ride, requiring determination and drawing him out of his solitude in the woods into a warmer, brighter place where there are other people, perhaps his home. The shake of the horse’s harness bells stands out as a bright spot in the poem—a reminder that the narrator needs to get back to his ride and travel the miles he will go so he can rest.

Another angle from which to think of the poem is through the relationship between the narrator and the woods—he is fascinated by them but he cannot stay, for he has to make it to his destination. Having somewhere to go conflicts with staying to rest and admire the woods. “The woods are lovely, dark and deep, / but I have promises to keep….” The woods are nature, and the narrator is a human who wants to be a part of the woods but cannot because he has an agenda to get through. It’s also interesting to note that the narrator doesn’t want the owner of the field to know he stops there, and says that his horse must think it a queer place to stop. He goes against what people think is normal when he stops alone in the woods on this winter night.

Maybe all of these perspectives can fit together in the ways they describe the narrator’s journey and his stopping. I think the narrator sees swirling, dark beauty and still peace in the woods and wants to stay there instead of going back to his responsibilities, but he goes on knowing he has places to go that are also beautiful in light and warmth. He cannot stay in the woods because he, like any other person, needs to stay close to others—the woods are a lonely place, and humans are not accustomed nor suited to living completely alone. What I see from the poem is that the closest he can be to these woods is to be refreshed in his journey by the beauty he finds briefly in their solitude. In this he is also urged on by the loneliness he feels as the only person there, and as the poem ends he continues on past the woods.

Monday, October 10, 2011

An Inconvenient Truth: Fifty Percent Wrong

The Orlando Essay was our focus this past week. Essays: that one familiar writing form which I could never seem to master. To be honest, I just wasn’t looking forward to writing it. Thinking, planning, writing, rewriting, revising, rewriting, editing, rewriting… my incoherent first draft didn’t look like it had much potential, and I started to find the whole writing process unappealing. So it was to my surprise that at the end of the week, I confidently handed in a paper that made a point. How did that change happen? It happened in part because I found out that I was wrong.
“At any given time, we as people are fifty percent wrong.” Mr. A’s quote was something like this. This statement fascinated me. I’m half wrong! Am I half wrong? Am I half right? What about my personality? My relationships? My beliefs?

With a little shame, I realized that it bothered me to think of being half wrong. For one thing, I unfortunately really like to be right. Being half wrong means I have to remember that quite often it’s others, not me, that are right.  This has drastic implications for my relationships. I felt my selfishness deflating as I thought of what it would mean to recognize every time I am wrong and someone else is right. Over the week, in fact, this idea kept coming back into my head and I kept reconsidering the way I talked to people. Do I tell them, with the way I act, that I think I am always right?

Another thing that I had a problem with was being half wrong about the things I considered my talents. I love to make music and I thought I was good at it, but stating that I am fifty percent wrong implies that I am not as good at playing my instrument as I thought I was. This rubbed me the wrong way. All this hard work and I am still fifty percent wrong when I play music? It almost made me angry. How is it possible to achieve anything if I am always going to be fifty percent wrong?

That question took on a new form when I thought about beliefs. My beliefs are central to the way I live—as anyone’s are. Beliefs influence our decisions, our words, our actions, our thoughts, and so many things about us. So I found myself in a dangerous place: I wanted to be one hundred percent right in my beliefs. I wanted to tell myself I was right because my beliefs are truth—but there I stopped myself. Do my beliefs all reflect truth? The hardest part about being fifty percent wrong boiled down to beliefs because they represent a person’s idea of what is ultimately right and good and fair. How could I live knowing my idea of truth was fifty percent wrong?

The way around this struggle is to realize that the fifty percent wrong is in me, not truth itself. Perhaps there is truth out there, but I can never fully understand it. Also, I am not and will never be perfect. I will just get the wrong ideas sometimes. In this way, I will always be partly wrong.

Does that mean that there’s no hope for me to accomplish anything? I don’t think so. The wonderful thing about knowing that you’re fifty percent wrong is that you know you always have something to learn. In my beliefs, if I am willing to have an open mind I will always be able to find out more about truth. In my skills, I will always be able to achieve more. And in my relationships, I will always have more to learn from others.

So, over the week, all of this contemplating ended up opening my mind to the fact that I, inconveniently to my selfish way of thinking, am wrong. The progress of my essay was allowed because of that. It was delightful to realize, through our lessons, that I was wrong about essay writing. I learned that it can be interesting and very engaging mentally, and because I knew my draft needed them, I used all of the tips I could get. I felt, for the first time, that I had produced a clear, interesting essay. I might be wrong about that. But this week I found out that when I know I’m half wrong, I have all the more opportunities to learn.