I commented on Ross's post "Dialectics: Ignorance and Happiness" and Kevin's post "Dialectics: Freedom and Happiness."
"Ross, you did a nice job exploring the relationship between ignorance and
happiness in this post. I like your analogy of a house cat; although it would be
nice to be ignorant and live for simple pleasures, when we begin grasping truth
life becomes much more meaningful. What you said about Neo made me think- you
described Neo's unhappiness with his life inside the Martrix and the happiness
he found upon escaping it. You speculate that Cipher must have been unhappy with
the Matrix in the first place, so when he goes back he will still probably be
dissatisfied. This made me question Cipher as a character. All of the people who
escaped the Matrix did so because they knew something wasn't right with it, so
Cipher must have known that. How could he imagine that he would be satisfied by
returning to the Matrix if he wasn't satisfied in the first place? Perhaps this
is excessive analysis, but I agree with your identification of Neo's story as
leaving ignorance to find a greater happiness, which makes me wonder how someone
who knows there is potential for something more than the shallow pleasure of
ignorance and has even sought deeper happiness before could turn back to an
ignorant life."
______________________________________________________________________________
"This is quite a good comparison- or tussle!- that you've set up, Kevin. From an
American perspective, it doesn't come naturally to see freedom and happiness
exclusively, but as your examples from the movie show, they can be very
separate. This distinction makes me wonder why we still value freedom so much.
There are some kinds of freedom that don't make you happy; especially that which
exposes you to a nasty reality that you didn't see when you weren't free. Maybe
our idea of freedom isn't as well-rounded as it could be in the U.S.
An
example that comes to mind is the unpleasant freedom that former slaves aquired
after the abolition of slavery in our country. My simple understanding of what
happened is this: for many of the freed, work opportunities other than the
manual labor jobs of their past were very scarce, both because they never were
educated and because discrimination closed much of society to them. In their
former conditions, they at least had certain work that gave them food to eat and
a place to live. One take on this situation is to see the certain existence as a
slave as happiness and the uncertain existence of being free as unhappiness, but
I guess that you could flip those things around depending on how you think of
it, as you said in the conclusion of your blog post. In this example, someone
who derives happiness from having power to decide how they live, not from
security of food and shelter, would say that the confined existence as a slave
is unhappiness and the free existence is happiness.
It seems that for
some people, the power (or perceived power) to do what they like is what makes
them happy- that's how they equate freedom with happiness. But freedom isn't
always defined as having the power to do what you like; sometimes freedom is
more along the lines of just having the power to not do what others would like
you to do."
Thoughts From Sophomore Academy English
Monday, May 14, 2012
Monday, May 7, 2012
Dialectics: Self and Truth
The search for truth is an archetype of human life: in nearly every civilization people have looked for explanations of our perceived reality, knowledge of right and wrong, something objectively correct outside of people, etc. Regardless of who they are, most people think that an understanding of reality that goes deeper than visual observation—truth—is important. In the movie The Matrix, a few characters sacrifice everything in order to find the truth and answer the questions they had in the backs of their minds. Neo, like the other characters that learned about the matrix, had the nagging feeling that something wasn’t right about the world, so he decided to give up the tolerable illusion of his life in the system in order to understand the real world as it was outside of that virtual one.
Why did Neo need to find out the truth so badly? It seems
like something inside him made him do it. When he had the choice to take the
blue pill to forget his questions and live as he had before or take the red
pill and get out of that life and see reality, he chose red. What was it about
Neo’s self that made him ask questions and take risks to find out the truth,
whereas other people in the matrix didn’t?
Perhaps his conscience told him to do it. After all, the
choice to burst out of ignorance and try to solve the problems of the world and
free others from them appears to be the right thing to do. Did Neo’s self make
him choose to learn the unpleasant truth because it’s morally his duty? In that
case, maybe he has some especially strong sense of right and wrong that others
don’t. However, what if Neo is only seeking the truth so that his self can be
satisfied? He couldn’t be happy until he knew what was really going on; maybe
he was more thoughtful than the people around him because he could tell
something was off, or maybe everyone around him had the same unhappiness but
they couldn’t identify it like he did.
Even if Neo chose to know the truth for his own satisfaction,
I don’t think that means he was wrong in deciding it. Satisfying one’s self’s
desire to know the truth can lead people to do good things: learning and
overcoming problems in the world seem to come from that desire to be satisfied.
Even if it was somewhat intrinsic of Neo to want the truth, I think that he
made a good decision.
Friday, April 27, 2012
Metacognition: Jane Eyre Mashup
It had come down to the morning of the day the project was due, and I sat down to my Jane Eyre Mashup to finish it off. I had four hours to work before I would be at a rehearsal for the rest of the day: four hours to finish, so I got down to business. I was completely absorbed in my work: I made connections, wrote, revised, cut and pasted, searched the internet, cited... and finally, hit ‘send’. I was done. I looked out the window and it was midday, but I hadn’t really noticed that abnormal feeling of being at home in the morning that I get when I have a day off of school. I was hungry, too, but lunch never crossed my mind. I almost made my mom late for work because my race against the clock hadn’t been created around her schedule. The world around me had almost completely disappeared for four hours, but it was good that I put that much effort into my project, right?
That thought left me as I hurried out the door and drove to school for rehearsal, but it came back later as I thought about how I concluded my mashup. In it, I wrote five paragraphs that ended up making some sort of claim about independence; I mainly took a look at how independent people act using all of my sources. The question that struck me was this: did I connect what I was doing to real life?
Because if it didn’t connect to real life, I didn’t see a reason to do it at all.
Of course, my sources were from real life. Some were from movies and books I had read, or things we did in class. But since my mind was somewhere other than in the computer chair in my kitchen on a Tuesday morning, I wondered if I could justify why it went there and what that place had to do with me in my kitchen. I’d reached the point where you’ve done so much work that you desperately need to grasp how it has helped you.
There’s always the book-learning helpfulness at school: learning facts and how to analyze, compare, and solve things are great things that human brains can do. However, there’s another type of learning for the weekends and times when we go out with our friends, and eventually for when we become independent adults and have to be a part of the world- hinted at so subtly in the inevitable math class question, “why are we learning this?”
I didn’t know, and I still don’t, whether what I wrote in my mashup can be something I will use in my personal life. Will I be an independent person like the ones I wrote about?
I think that if I hadn’t been in such a hurry to finish making scholarly connections (which were necessary for the project) and analyzing this theme, I might have come back from the faraway intellectual place I went to and spent some time connecting what I had discovered to real life. My mashup could have used a direct address to the reader’s life and how they could be independent. This is the ‘so what’ that English teachers talk about: how your writing tells the reader that this matters not only intellectually but personally in their life.
The way I was thinking was only part of the process. To make my work complete, I needed to take some time away from the intellectual analysis I’d done and apply it to life on the streets. I’m glad I spent so much time in that analytical mindset because I think this project took me as far (possibly farther) in that direction as I have ever been, but I should have given myself time to come back to my kitchen chair on a Tuesday morning.
That thought left me as I hurried out the door and drove to school for rehearsal, but it came back later as I thought about how I concluded my mashup. In it, I wrote five paragraphs that ended up making some sort of claim about independence; I mainly took a look at how independent people act using all of my sources. The question that struck me was this: did I connect what I was doing to real life?
Because if it didn’t connect to real life, I didn’t see a reason to do it at all.
Of course, my sources were from real life. Some were from movies and books I had read, or things we did in class. But since my mind was somewhere other than in the computer chair in my kitchen on a Tuesday morning, I wondered if I could justify why it went there and what that place had to do with me in my kitchen. I’d reached the point where you’ve done so much work that you desperately need to grasp how it has helped you.
There’s always the book-learning helpfulness at school: learning facts and how to analyze, compare, and solve things are great things that human brains can do. However, there’s another type of learning for the weekends and times when we go out with our friends, and eventually for when we become independent adults and have to be a part of the world- hinted at so subtly in the inevitable math class question, “why are we learning this?”
I didn’t know, and I still don’t, whether what I wrote in my mashup can be something I will use in my personal life. Will I be an independent person like the ones I wrote about?
I think that if I hadn’t been in such a hurry to finish making scholarly connections (which were necessary for the project) and analyzing this theme, I might have come back from the faraway intellectual place I went to and spent some time connecting what I had discovered to real life. My mashup could have used a direct address to the reader’s life and how they could be independent. This is the ‘so what’ that English teachers talk about: how your writing tells the reader that this matters not only intellectually but personally in their life.
The way I was thinking was only part of the process. To make my work complete, I needed to take some time away from the intellectual analysis I’d done and apply it to life on the streets. I’m glad I spent so much time in that analytical mindset because I think this project took me as far (possibly farther) in that direction as I have ever been, but I should have given myself time to come back to my kitchen chair on a Tuesday morning.
Saturday, April 7, 2012
Blog 5: Thoughts on the Play
A Midsummer Night’s Dream at the Chicago Shakespeare Theatre was beautiful, except now I’m not sure I can wake up.
Puck was the last character to appear on stage, and he was kindly, if almost condescendingly, consoling when he said, “If we shadows have offended, / Think but this, and all is mended, / That you have but slumber'd here/ While these visions did appear. / And this weak and idle theme, / No more yielding but a dream, / Gentles, do not reprehend: / if you pardon, we will mend….” The shadows Puck speaks of—fairies and lovers and actors—hadn’t offended me; on the contrary, I was enthralled by them. But when Puck reminded me that this was a play, I could regard them only as a daydream, and when I left them, I couldn’t shake the feeling that I was dreaming.
My first reaction to the idea of explaining drama so as to comfort those with delicate dispositions, which was presented in the play with Pyramus and Thisbe as well as in Puck’s monologue, was scoffing mixed with a little artistic horror. I scoffed that they need worry about people being shaken by a pretend lion or a fairy story, and I felt a hint of the horror that theatre enthusiasts might find upon seeing all things dramatic cut out of drama with the assurance of, ‘Don’t worry, it’s not real.’
But looking again at the lines Puck said, this idea has become more serious for me. His use of dreams to avoid making an impression was the hook that caught and detained me. Many times before I’ve found myself thinking of the past as a dream, because both are immaterial. Our memory is all we have of the past because we can’t experience it again, but through that perception we trust that it happened and we base the present off of it.
Dreams are just like memories, but they haven’t actually happened. Everybody knows the feeling of waking up and being disappointed, confused, or relieved that what they‘ve just experienced in their dreams wasn’t real. In A Midsummer Night’s Dream, by suggesting that the play I had just watched and felt was not a real event but a dream, Puck sent my mind scrambling and made me feel like I was still dreaming.
If I couldn’t trust the story I had just become a part of, then how could I trust my own story every day? Posing this question aloud sounds silly, but it has been fermenting in the back of my mind ever since I walked out of the theatre. The one distinction between reality and stories and dreams that comes to mind for me is that when we experience them, we tell ourselves that stories and dreams are not reality and that personal, physical experiences are. As I learned from A Midsummer Night’s Dream, strange things happen when we don’t correctly tell ourselves what is reality and what’s not.
Friday, March 23, 2012
Metacognition: Writing a Short Story
Creative inspiration is a mystery to me. I don’t know where ideas come from, but I often feel that they aren’t always accessible when we want them. There’s a quote from Jack London that my Language Arts teacher told me in junior high: “You can’t wait for inspiration. You have to go after it with a club.” As I first sat down to write a story fragment, inspiration was scarce; I decided to take drastic measures and write whatever word I thought of first. “Ahem.”
So that was the first word of my story. It sounds strange, but that word inspired a scene when I tried to capture the feeling it gave me, which gradually developed into a story. I don’t know that this method always works—in fact, I find it peculiar that it worked for me.
Yet, I remember having a feeling of being somewhere you’ve been countless times and having to do what you don’t want to do; that’s what translated into my first scene. In actuality, I felt that way because I was sitting at my computer with writer’s block, but it translated into my character’s boredom as he listened to a speaker tell him and his fellow inmates at a correctional facility how they could improve their situations.
Is writing about how we feel in the present moment? Maybe those feelings that struggle to become words are inspiration. I haven’t thought about where I get ideas enough to know whether this is always how creativity works for me, but it’s plausible. Moods are heavily influential on art; the fact that art can convey feeling is why we treasure it so much.
However, I don’t like the arbitrary nature of this idea-finding. What if there’s no nagging feeling that needs to be written down at present? I don’t think that artists or writers can always rely on their immediate thoughts to create: they have to go outside of the present moment. As far as I can see it, it’s almost like they take their mind out of their present surroundings and put it into a different place. For a writer it might be the perspective of a character or even just the setting of a story. For an artist it could be a different way of seeing something, or seeing something other than what they normally see.
That inspiration is like Jack London said it is: it’s intentional. My method was more purposeful than just waiting for an idea to materialize, but I didn’t consciously bring my thinking into a different perspective. I’d like to directly try that in the future; I guess that has been what our teachers have asked of us in past writing assignments, but I didn’t think of it this way. My current English teacher’s advice during this process was just to sit down and write something. You’re not getting anywhere if you’re only thinking in front of a blank page. Imagination doesn’t have to rely on chance. The action of putting your mind to it—putting your mind in your work and escaping your literal location—is a way to find inspiration on purpose.
Monday, March 12, 2012
Change of Mind
Once
Once is a love story. The guy meets the girl, who he pushes away at first, but then they start to like each other and they end up becoming friends and knowing each other well. They both have had broken-off relationships that they talk about, but they seem happy together. Then the time comes for the guy to return to his first girlfriend, and the girl’s husband soon will show up, so they each go their separate ways—the girl with the piano that the guy gave her because she’s always wanted it, and him with an album she helped him write and perform. As the movie ends, the guy has gone back to his girlfriend in London and the girl plays piano in her home as her husband and daughter play in the background, and all are content.
My reaction to this ending was something along the lines of, “what?” What about true love? In most of the love stories I’ve known, the couples struggle with and eventually overcome any obstacles so that they can be together. Why didn’t this guy and this girl end up together, and how could this be a genuinely happy ending?
These questions made an appearance in our discussion afterwards. As we talked, I gradually realized that even though they didn’t spend the rest of their lives together, the guy and the girl impacted each other deeply through their connection. Someone made the comparison between this story and Romeo and Juliet, and as I saw more differences between the stories I started to question my idea of romantic love. Mainly my question was, is love only real if it lasts?
Before, I would have said yes. Romeo’s love for Rosaline mustn’t have been real love, because he was engrossed in it for a short time but immediately fell for another girl at first sight. And most married people would tell you that although they had other relationships before they knew their spouse, the one they love is who they’re married to. That, in my thinking, was love—when people care so much that they want to spend the rest of their lives together.
Once changed this thinking. Even though the guy and the girl didn’t stay together, what they had was certainly real and it changed them both for the better. Something we discussed in class was that they both gave to the other and provided a fresh perspective on the other’s situation. They helped each other progress as musicians, for one thing. Playing instruments and singing together was an intimate experience that they each came away from with something new. They also helped to open the other’s mind towards their old relationships. Both were living apart from someone they had loved, yet they weren’t completely separated. The guy was betrayed by his girlfriend but still loved her, which he realized through conversations with the girl. And she realized that it would best for her daughter to have her father around, even though she had left him.
And because they had opened up to each other, they split apart. They knew each other for only a week or two, but as I discovered in class, that was all they needed. For some reason, maybe because of all of those happy-ending, fairy-tale-esque love stories out there in our culture, I had expected them to throw out their other connections so that they could stay together. I was almost angry that they didn’t. It seemed like they were cheating themselves out of a good relationship. But to counter that thought, someone asked what more their relationship needed to be. Did it need to be physical instead of just emotional? Not really. Did they need to know each other better? No, they knew each other—not by knowing every detail of their lives, but by knowing the other’s emotions so well. They didn’t need anything else, which was what surprised me.
I’d always thought that the real and beneficial relationships last on into marriage and aging together, but now I see it differently. The story in Once shows that even two weeks of being in love can bring about good changes in people. That makes a significant difference in my view of dating, the way a lot of modern relationships start. In my old mindset it was hard to see the point of dating without continuing on to a lifelong relationship, because I didn’t realize that true love can be short. Now it’s easier to see that love comes in different forms and doesn’t have to last to be something great.
Friday, February 10, 2012
Carry It Forward: Masking Cruelty
People who seem great can resort to acts of brutality without checking themselves, and others blindly follow along.
In Heart of Darkness by Joseph Conrad, Mr. Kurtz is one such person. Mr. Kurtz had “immense plans” for his work—he wanted to “exert a power for good practically unbounded” over the Africans, but in fact he was saying white people were superior so they should kill and take all they wanted in Africa. His own reasoning destroyed any restraint or conscience he might have had; he stopped himself from seeing that he was doing awful things. And when he did those things nobody else stopped him because either they didn’t know about him or they didn’t see the full extent of what he had done.
Marlow, upon discovering the darkness at Kurtz’s core and returning to Belgium, says about the normal people he sees hurrying about that he “felt so sure they could not possibly know the things I knew.” And most of them probably didn’t know what was going on in the Congo. They probably didn’t care to know. Why should they?
The other people that followed Kurtz’s brutality didn’t see what was wrong about it because Kurtz convinced them he had good intentions and they didn’t question him. Marlow emphasizes Kurtz’s eloquent writing: “he soared and took me with him.” The way his plans and perspective were presented drew people in and made them forget to examine ideas before accepting them. Because they didn’t look closely—and perhaps they didn’t dare to—most of the Company men who worked with Kurtz in Heart of Darkness didn’t allow themselves to realize how brutal Kurtz really was.
These ideas stay with me because we see people justify cruel actions with ideas they seem to sincerely believe today. One example that comes to mind is the LRA in Uganda: somehow those soldiers are convinced that it is okay for them to injure and kill people, destroy villages, and force children to fight. Actions like that make me wonder at how strong ideas can be. Even if a person lies to their conscience by saying cruelty is alright, that reasoning is still strong enough to allow them to do cruel things.
But people aren’t always lying; sometimes they just believe in the reasoning for wrong actions because they never thought to question it. We can see this in mundane situations in our own lives. Like the Belgians that Marlow scoffs at who are ignorant of their countrymen’s acts in the Congo, we are losing touch with what our increasingly connected lifestyle means for the people on the other end. For example, American consumers’ desire to pay low prices could cause people on the other side of the world to live at poverty level with bare-minimum wage factory jobs, and we might not even know about it. We can say that we wouldn’t wish that struggle on anybody, but we could easily be supporting it with our lifestyle.
Whether it’s something extreme like war or indirect like bad jobs in other countries, people in our world do things that their consciences would normally prevent them from doing because they don’t think about them for what they are. It’s important that we are aware of the consequences of our actions and that we fully consider the reasoning behind what we do.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)