Monday, October 10, 2011

An Inconvenient Truth: Fifty Percent Wrong

The Orlando Essay was our focus this past week. Essays: that one familiar writing form which I could never seem to master. To be honest, I just wasn’t looking forward to writing it. Thinking, planning, writing, rewriting, revising, rewriting, editing, rewriting… my incoherent first draft didn’t look like it had much potential, and I started to find the whole writing process unappealing. So it was to my surprise that at the end of the week, I confidently handed in a paper that made a point. How did that change happen? It happened in part because I found out that I was wrong.
“At any given time, we as people are fifty percent wrong.” Mr. A’s quote was something like this. This statement fascinated me. I’m half wrong! Am I half wrong? Am I half right? What about my personality? My relationships? My beliefs?

With a little shame, I realized that it bothered me to think of being half wrong. For one thing, I unfortunately really like to be right. Being half wrong means I have to remember that quite often it’s others, not me, that are right.  This has drastic implications for my relationships. I felt my selfishness deflating as I thought of what it would mean to recognize every time I am wrong and someone else is right. Over the week, in fact, this idea kept coming back into my head and I kept reconsidering the way I talked to people. Do I tell them, with the way I act, that I think I am always right?

Another thing that I had a problem with was being half wrong about the things I considered my talents. I love to make music and I thought I was good at it, but stating that I am fifty percent wrong implies that I am not as good at playing my instrument as I thought I was. This rubbed me the wrong way. All this hard work and I am still fifty percent wrong when I play music? It almost made me angry. How is it possible to achieve anything if I am always going to be fifty percent wrong?

That question took on a new form when I thought about beliefs. My beliefs are central to the way I live—as anyone’s are. Beliefs influence our decisions, our words, our actions, our thoughts, and so many things about us. So I found myself in a dangerous place: I wanted to be one hundred percent right in my beliefs. I wanted to tell myself I was right because my beliefs are truth—but there I stopped myself. Do my beliefs all reflect truth? The hardest part about being fifty percent wrong boiled down to beliefs because they represent a person’s idea of what is ultimately right and good and fair. How could I live knowing my idea of truth was fifty percent wrong?

The way around this struggle is to realize that the fifty percent wrong is in me, not truth itself. Perhaps there is truth out there, but I can never fully understand it. Also, I am not and will never be perfect. I will just get the wrong ideas sometimes. In this way, I will always be partly wrong.

Does that mean that there’s no hope for me to accomplish anything? I don’t think so. The wonderful thing about knowing that you’re fifty percent wrong is that you know you always have something to learn. In my beliefs, if I am willing to have an open mind I will always be able to find out more about truth. In my skills, I will always be able to achieve more. And in my relationships, I will always have more to learn from others.

So, over the week, all of this contemplating ended up opening my mind to the fact that I, inconveniently to my selfish way of thinking, am wrong. The progress of my essay was allowed because of that. It was delightful to realize, through our lessons, that I was wrong about essay writing. I learned that it can be interesting and very engaging mentally, and because I knew my draft needed them, I used all of the tips I could get. I felt, for the first time, that I had produced a clear, interesting essay. I might be wrong about that. But this week I found out that when I know I’m half wrong, I have all the more opportunities to learn.

2 comments:

  1. Kathryn! Just like you were introduced to the idea of being fifty percent wrong by your English teacher, I have now been introduced to the idea by you, and begun to think about it myself.

    Like you talked about, the idea of being fifty percent wrong all the time can be frustrating. There are tons of things everyday that I just assume I am right about; namely (like Kathryn mentioned) my beliefs. I do this every day and never really notice it; however, they have a profound affect on my life. If I can’t have confidence that even the things I believe in most strongly are fully accurate, how am I supposed to even have beliefs about anything? A belief (whether it be which religion you follow or which football team is superior) is something you believe in. How am I supposed to believe in anything if I already know I am half wrong all the time?

    Like you, I have found a way to come to terms with it. I take being “fifty percent wrong” to mean that I am never correct about everything I know. However, this doesn’t mean that I don’t know anything, or am wrong about everything. I see this fact as an opportunity to have a constant learning experience throughout my life; to take what I don’t know yet fully and pursue it until I know as much as possible. In the same way, I don’t see it to mean that everything I believe is wrong, just in a constant state of philosophical evolution. Especially now, in adolescence, my ideas are changing and growing all the time; this doesn’t mean I didn’t know anything before, it just means that I know more now to change the way I think about something. Neither state of belief was necessarily incorrect, just incomplete, and now I am ok with accepting that my beliefs are still incomplete even now. Knowing that I am fifty percent wrong all the time doesn’t have to make me stop believing it anything, rather is makes me more open to ideas since I realize that I might not have the full picture yet.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi, Kathryn! I really enjoyed reading this post because previously, I had never thought about my thinking in that sort of way. My thoughts and beliefs had always been my thoughts and beliefs. I had never thought of them as right or wrong. More than anything, I found myself questioning what exactly the quote you mentioned actually means…. What does it mean to be wrong?

    After all, the mere act of labeling something as wrong inherently assumes that there is a correct answer. But, are there really correct thoughts or beliefs? I would say the inner workings of the mind are far too complex and wispy to judge that way. Just as we have been discussing in class, a single object or idea can be looked upon with an endless number of perspectives, so how can we say which is the best? And, that brings up another big question: who exactly is this judge?

    The most likely answer to this question is “society”. Standards of right and wrong are established in almost every society when it comes to laws and guidelines of behavior. However, that is action. Thought is one level deeper and is stored inside a single person. Private. Does society really have the right to set standards at that level?

    Now, I may be misinterpreting the quote altogether. Perhaps the speaker was simply referring to the miscellaneous trivia each person collects over the years, which is mistakenly believed to be true. In that case, I completely agree with your reaction of humility. We should certainly not take our knowledge for granted, and an open mind is invaluable so that we do not shut ourselves out from learning.

    So, I suppose one could differentiate “thoughts and beliefs” from “trivia and knowledge”, or miscellaneous tidbits from big ideas which can really impact one’s behavior. The quote doesn’t really specify. However, there is some value in pondering about it. Doing so has allowed me to analyze the roots of my thoughts and how they formed. And, when it comes to my own mind, I really don’t know the half of it (no pun intended… well, yes it was). Thanks, Kathryn, for the great writing!

    ReplyDelete