Once is a love story. The guy meets the girl, who he pushes away at first, but then they start to like each other and they end up becoming friends and knowing each other well. They both have had broken-off relationships that they talk about, but they seem happy together. Then the time comes for the guy to return to his first girlfriend, and the girl’s husband soon will show up, so they each go their separate ways—the girl with the piano that the guy gave her because she’s always wanted it, and him with an album she helped him write and perform. As the movie ends, the guy has gone back to his girlfriend in London and the girl plays piano in her home as her husband and daughter play in the background, and all are content.
My reaction to this ending was something along the lines of, “what?” What about true love? In most of the love stories I’ve known, the couples struggle with and eventually overcome any obstacles so that they can be together. Why didn’t this guy and this girl end up together, and how could this be a genuinely happy ending?
These questions made an appearance in our discussion afterwards. As we talked, I gradually realized that even though they didn’t spend the rest of their lives together, the guy and the girl impacted each other deeply through their connection. Someone made the comparison between this story and Romeo and Juliet, and as I saw more differences between the stories I started to question my idea of romantic love. Mainly my question was, is love only real if it lasts?
Before, I would have said yes. Romeo’s love for Rosaline mustn’t have been real love, because he was engrossed in it for a short time but immediately fell for another girl at first sight. And most married people would tell you that although they had other relationships before they knew their spouse, the one they love is who they’re married to. That, in my thinking, was love—when people care so much that they want to spend the rest of their lives together.
Once changed this thinking. Even though the guy and the girl didn’t stay together, what they had was certainly real and it changed them both for the better. Something we discussed in class was that they both gave to the other and provided a fresh perspective on the other’s situation. They helped each other progress as musicians, for one thing. Playing instruments and singing together was an intimate experience that they each came away from with something new. They also helped to open the other’s mind towards their old relationships. Both were living apart from someone they had loved, yet they weren’t completely separated. The guy was betrayed by his girlfriend but still loved her, which he realized through conversations with the girl. And she realized that it would best for her daughter to have her father around, even though she had left him.
And because they had opened up to each other, they split apart. They knew each other for only a week or two, but as I discovered in class, that was all they needed. For some reason, maybe because of all of those happy-ending, fairy-tale-esque love stories out there in our culture, I had expected them to throw out their other connections so that they could stay together. I was almost angry that they didn’t. It seemed like they were cheating themselves out of a good relationship. But to counter that thought, someone asked what more their relationship needed to be. Did it need to be physical instead of just emotional? Not really. Did they need to know each other better? No, they knew each other—not by knowing every detail of their lives, but by knowing the other’s emotions so well. They didn’t need anything else, which was what surprised me.
I’d always thought that the real and beneficial relationships last on into marriage and aging together, but now I see it differently. The story in Once shows that even two weeks of being in love can bring about good changes in people. That makes a significant difference in my view of dating, the way a lot of modern relationships start. In my old mindset it was hard to see the point of dating without continuing on to a lifelong relationship, because I didn’t realize that true love can be short. Now it’s easier to see that love comes in different forms and doesn’t have to last to be something great.
No comments:
Post a Comment