Monday, May 14, 2012

bLOgGiNg ARoUnD

I commented on Ross's post "Dialectics: Ignorance and Happiness" and Kevin's post "Dialectics: Freedom and Happiness."

"Ross, you did a nice job exploring the relationship between ignorance and happiness in this post. I like your analogy of a house cat; although it would be nice to be ignorant and live for simple pleasures, when we begin grasping truth life becomes much more meaningful. What you said about Neo made me think- you described Neo's unhappiness with his life inside the Martrix and the happiness he found upon escaping it. You speculate that Cipher must have been unhappy with the Matrix in the first place, so when he goes back he will still probably be dissatisfied. This made me question Cipher as a character. All of the people who escaped the Matrix did so because they knew something wasn't right with it, so Cipher must have known that. How could he imagine that he would be satisfied by returning to the Matrix if he wasn't satisfied in the first place? Perhaps this is excessive analysis, but I agree with your identification of Neo's story as leaving ignorance to find a greater happiness, which makes me wonder how someone who knows there is potential for something more than the shallow pleasure of ignorance and has even sought deeper happiness before could turn back to an ignorant life."

______________________________________________________________________________

"This is quite a good comparison- or tussle!- that you've set up, Kevin. From an American perspective, it doesn't come naturally to see freedom and happiness exclusively, but as your examples from the movie show, they can be very separate. This distinction makes me wonder why we still value freedom so much. There are some kinds of freedom that don't make you happy; especially that which exposes you to a nasty reality that you didn't see when you weren't free. Maybe our idea of freedom isn't as well-rounded as it could be in the U.S.

An example that comes to mind is the unpleasant freedom that former slaves aquired after the abolition of slavery in our country. My simple understanding of what happened is this: for many of the freed, work opportunities other than the manual labor jobs of their past were very scarce, both because they never were educated and because discrimination closed much of society to them. In their former conditions, they at least had certain work that gave them food to eat and a place to live. One take on this situation is to see the certain existence as a slave as happiness and the uncertain existence of being free as unhappiness, but I guess that you could flip those things around depending on how you think of it, as you said in the conclusion of your blog post. In this example, someone who derives happiness from having power to decide how they live, not from security of food and shelter, would say that the confined existence as a slave is unhappiness and the free existence is happiness.

It seems that for some people, the power (or perceived power) to do what they like is what makes them happy- that's how they equate freedom with happiness. But freedom isn't always defined as having the power to do what you like; sometimes freedom is more along the lines of just having the power to not do what others would like you to do."

No comments:

Post a Comment