In Heart of Darkness by Joseph Conrad, Mr. Kurtz is one such person. Mr. Kurtz had “immense plans” for his work—he wanted to “exert a power for good practically unbounded” over the Africans, but in fact he was saying white people were superior so they should kill and take all they wanted in Africa. His own reasoning destroyed any restraint or conscience he might have had; he stopped himself from seeing that he was doing awful things. And when he did those things nobody else stopped him because either they didn’t know about him or they didn’t see the full extent of what he had done.
Marlow, upon discovering the darkness at Kurtz’s core and returning to Belgium, says about the normal people he sees hurrying about that he “felt so sure they could not possibly know the things I knew.” And most of them probably didn’t know what was going on in the Congo. They probably didn’t care to know. Why should they?
The other people that followed Kurtz’s brutality didn’t see what was wrong about it because Kurtz convinced them he had good intentions and they didn’t question him. Marlow emphasizes Kurtz’s eloquent writing: “he soared and took me with him.” The way his plans and perspective were presented drew people in and made them forget to examine ideas before accepting them. Because they didn’t look closely—and perhaps they didn’t dare to—most of the Company men who worked with Kurtz in Heart of Darkness didn’t allow themselves to realize how brutal Kurtz really was.
These ideas stay with me because we see people justify cruel actions with ideas they seem to sincerely believe today. One example that comes to mind is the LRA in Uganda: somehow those soldiers are convinced that it is okay for them to injure and kill people, destroy villages, and force children to fight. Actions like that make me wonder at how strong ideas can be. Even if a person lies to their conscience by saying cruelty is alright, that reasoning is still strong enough to allow them to do cruel things.
But people aren’t always lying; sometimes they just believe in the reasoning for wrong actions because they never thought to question it. We can see this in mundane situations in our own lives. Like the Belgians that Marlow scoffs at who are ignorant of their countrymen’s acts in the Congo, we are losing touch with what our increasingly connected lifestyle means for the people on the other end. For example, American consumers’ desire to pay low prices could cause people on the other side of the world to live at poverty level with bare-minimum wage factory jobs, and we might not even know about it. We can say that we wouldn’t wish that struggle on anybody, but we could easily be supporting it with our lifestyle.
Whether it’s something extreme like war or indirect like bad jobs in other countries, people in our world do things that their consciences would normally prevent them from doing because they don’t think about them for what they are. It’s important that we are aware of the consequences of our actions and that we fully consider the reasoning behind what we do.
I agree that there are many people who live in ignorance and therefore don’t know that they are aiding some force of evil, but this raises the question of whether they should be living in ignorance and whether people are responsible for the decisions they make in ignorance. Post-modernism would say that we always live in some degree of ignorance because we can only see one piece of the system we live in. It is impossible to fully determine the truth. Therefore, we always live in a world of uncertainty. Yet being uncertain does not preclude action. Uncertainty is inevitable so the best plan of action is to minimize that uncertainty and make a decision. Does that mean we are responsible for actions despite our ignorance? Of course. If you didn’t know that a red light meant to stop, you would still get a ticket. Nobody knows exactly what working conditions are like at a factory in China. Only the factory owner has access to that information. But there is plenty of information that is public that suggests that the conditions in those factories are poor. It is our responsibility to use that information when making decisions.
ReplyDeleteThis doesn’t mean I’m necessarily saying that it is wrong to buy such products. I just believe that we should take into account the information we have, even if limited. The more difficult question is whether the costs of these products outweigh the benefits we reap from them. This is a whole other discussion that I couldn’t even fit into this post. But being responsible for the information that allows us to determine this question is at least a good starting point.